There is a widespread belief in the Spanish business world: the idea that setting up a limited liability company (S.L.) automatically creates an impassable wall between business risk and the founder's personal assets.
However, in legal and tax practice, this protection is not absolute. Limited liability, recognised in article 1.2 of the Spanish Companies Act (TRLSC), is one of the essential principles of capital companies, but it does not rule out personal liability in the cases provided for by law.
When business owners run the company as an extension of their personal assets, or manage a web of companies without proper asset and organisational separation, significant legal risks can arise.
1. The Doctrine of Piercing the Corporate Veil and Commingling of Assets
Spanish law starts from the principle of separate legal personality: each company owns its own assets and is liable for its own obligations, with no group-wide pool of assets and no automatic transfer of debts between related companies.
However, the courts allow, on an exceptional basis, the doctrine of piercing the corporate veil when it is proven that legal personality is being used abusively or fraudulently to evade liability to third parties.
⚠️ Factors that May Justify Piercing the Veil
- Commingling of assets and cash: transfers of funds between related companies or to partners without economic justification or proper contractual or corporate documentation.
- Material undercapitalisation: using clearly under-funded companies to take on certain risks, together with actions that may reveal an abuse of legal personality.
- Mixing of bodies and resources: using staff, premises or resources of different companies interchangeably without properly delimiting their respective activities and operations.
These circumstances may be relevant indications, but on their own they do not lead to piercing the veil. An abusive use of legal personality must be proven that justifies, given the circumstances of the case, departing from the general rule of asset separation.
The Spanish Supreme Court reiterated this in its Judgment 1205/2026 of 17 July, stressing the exceptional nature of this doctrine and the need to prove the conditions that justify applying it.
2. The Risk of De Facto Director Status in Company Groups
In family businesses that grow by accumulating several sister companies (owned directly by individuals), or in groups with a poorly defined organisation, a second significant risk emerges: possible classification as a de facto director.
Article 236.3 TRLSC extends directors' liability to those who effectively perform management functions without formally holding the position, and to the persons on whose instructions the formally appointed directors act.
However, this classification requires proof of the effective exercise of management functions or a decisive influence over the formal board's actions. Simply being a majority shareholder, or legitimately exercising strategic direction within a group, does not automatically mean there is a de facto director.
📌 The Line between Lawful Unified Direction and De Facto Management
- Legitimate unified direction: a holding company exercises its rights as a shareholder, takes part in appointing its subsidiaries' boards, sets general strategic guidelines and establishes the group's coordination mechanisms.
- De facto management: the individual shareholder or the parent's managers effectively take on the subsidiary director's functions, give decisive instructions on its management or in practice replace the formally appointed board.
This distinction is especially important because a de facto director's liability can extend both to damage caused by acts contrary to the law, the articles of association or the duties of the position (article 236 TRLSC) and to certain cases of liability for company debts (article 367 TRLSC).
In any case, liability is not automatic. It requires the conditions established for each regime to be met. In particular, liability under article 367 TRLSC is linked to failure to meet the legal duties arising when grounds for dissolution exist, and covers company obligations within the time frame set out in that article, subject to the legal exceptions.
3. Legitimate Tax Planning vs. the Anti-Abuse Clause: Valid Business Reasons and Accounting Rigour
To organise operational risk and accumulated business assets (property, surplus cash and shareholdings), it may be advisable to move from a set of isolated companies to a holding company structure.
This reorganisation can be carried out through operations such as a share exchange (article 76.5 of the Spanish Corporate Income Tax Act, LIS), a spin-off (article 76.2 LIS) or the corporate segregation of business lines regulated in article 61 of Royal Decree-law 5/2023, whose tax treatment must be analysed according to the applicable requirements, in particular those of article 76.3 LIS where relevant.
These operations may qualify for the special tax regime for restructurings, which allows tax on certain latent gains to be deferred when the legal requirements are met.
From an accounting point of view, transactions between group companies must be analysed under Recognition and Measurement Standard 21 of the Spanish General Accounting Plan (PGC), which sets specific criteria for certain reorganisations; the same measurement rule does not apply in every case.
On the tax side, the line between legitimate tax planning (lawfully choosing the most efficient corporate and tax structure the law offers) and tax abuse lies mainly in the anti-abuse clause of article 89.2 LIS.
This provision prevents the special regime from applying when the main objective of the operation is tax fraud or evasion, particularly when it does not respond to valid business reasons and merely seeks a tax advantage.
For example, interposing a holding company before distributing dividends or transferring shares may require especially careful analysis, taking into account the possible application of the article 21 LIS exemption, whose scope depends on meeting its legal requirements.
That said, obtaining a tax advantage does not on its own make a reorganisation abusive.
In this regard, Supreme Court Judgment 949/2026 of 20 July highlighted the need to respect the principle of proportionality when applying the anti-abuse clause, so that any reassessment is limited to removing the proven abusive tax advantages. It also requires stronger reasoning when the authorities seek to remove the deferral of latent gains on the grounds that it was the main objective of the operation.
For its part, the Central Economic-Administrative Court, in its Resolution of 8 October 2026 (RG 417/2023), went further into the treatment of these operations, especially when holding companies are involved and profits generated before the restructuring are distributed.
It is therefore essential that the reorganisation responds to real, documented and provable business reasons, which may include:
- Centralising strategic direction and, where appropriate, the effective provision of shared administrative or financial services.
- Separating activities and operational risks through a coherent corporate organisation and proper delimitation of relationships between entities.
- Asset organisation and succession planning for the family business, analysing, where relevant, the requirements for the Wealth Tax exemption (article 4.Eight of Act 19/1991), its effect on the Temporary Solidarity Tax on Large Fortunes and the reductions provided for in Inheritance and Gift Tax (articles 20.2.c and 20.6 of Act 29/1987), together with the applicable regional legislation.
Having a holding structure does not in itself guarantee access to these tax benefits, which will depend on meeting the requirements set for each case.
4. Corporate Architecture and Governance with Pausa Fiscal
Legal, Accounting and Tax Protection for Business Groups
At Pausa Fiscal we don't just file taxes. We design the complete corporate architecture of family groups and growing companies so that business growth comes with proper asset organisation and preventive management of legal and tax risks.
We analyse the corporate and accounting feasibility of each operation, document the business reasons for restructurings, formalise related-party contracts and set the corporate governance rules needed to strengthen legal certainty and reduce the liability risks of the founder and the board.
🏛️ High-Level Tax and Corporate Architecture
- Holding structures and reorganisations (RDL 5/2023 and LIS): share exchanges, spin-offs and segregations, analysing whether the tax-neutral regime may apply and the requirements to be met.
- Corporate governance and director protection: family protocols, shareholder agreements and delimitation of roles and responsibilities to prevent situations that could lead to piercing the veil or de facto director status.
- Family business tax planning: review of compliance with the requirements for Wealth Tax, Large Fortunes Tax, Inheritance and Gift Tax and the dividend regime.
Editorial note: we especially thank José Ángel López-García de la Serrana Palomares for his collaboration and technical review of the legal content of this article.